James welcomes his guests Anna Chlumksy and Charlie Day and the conversation quickly turns to Valentine’s Day and then Charlie’s recent birthday which involved a significant amount of sake. Then James gets a Chicago accent lesson from Anna Chlumsky before sharing with Charlie Day an online petition that wants Charlie to know his voice is “beautiful.” Then Anna shares the peculiar way she spent her time as an only-child and Charlie recalls how susceptible he is to peer pressure, especially if it’s to get a laugh.